Epic showdown between these two Sichuan powerhouses in Charlottesville.

Water boiled fish 水煮鱼 - Taste of China
As many of you know, the ever elusive Chef Peter Chang first came to Charlottesville back in 2009, opening up Taste of China. But that brief stint brought reporters and media and way too many customers than the restaurant can handle, so after around several months, this nomad chef was once again out of here. There were rumors of why he left: didn’t get along with management, didn’t like to stay anywhere for too long, hating the media’s attention, but who knows? Now, in 2011, Peter Chang came back to open up Peter Chang’s China Grill, once again serving Sichuan cuisine. So which is the better restaurant?

Shredded and spicy tofu skin - China Grill
Before I start, as a disclaimer, this is only my opinion and certainly not the end-all-be-all of reviews.
The Food
I have been to Taste of China many many times over these last two years, and their food has always been top-notch. After Chang left, everyone was worried about how the quality of food was not going to be as good or as authentic. Honestly, I thought the food was great. The portions are nice and big. I especially have to point out their soups. They have several kinds of those broths that are cooked in a big clay pot for hours and hours, and this is the real stuff. This is the type of nutritious and delicious pork bone or rib soups that Chinese grandmas will make in the kitchen all day. I definitely recommend getting one of those soups if you are going in a large group because the portion size is humongous.

Seaweed, tofu, and pork rib soup - Taste of China

Mouth watering chicken 口水鸡 - Taste of China

Chicken with green peppers in hot pot - Taste of China
While the food at China Grill was good, it didn’t live up to all the hype. Perhaps I expected too much? The “Water boiled fish” is supposed to be extremely spicy to the point where your tongue is falling out, but it barely had any spice to it. The soup dumplings were good, but nothing to rave about. Their “Yu Xiang pork,” however, was amazing. I have to give them credit for that. I’m really picky about this dish because it’s my favorite, and chefs usually screw it up. But not here. This particular dish was a standout for me.

Water boiled fish - China Grill

Yu Xiang pork 鱼香肉丝 - China Grill

White hot fish and rice vermicelli casserole - China Grill
Overall, concerning the food, the two places are equals.

Soup Dumplings - Taste of China

Soup Dumplings - China Grill
The Service
But the real difference is in the service. I have eaten at China Grill two times, and both times, I left nearly fuming due to the service. The front of the house was perfectly cordial (although I was a little perturbed when I tried to order in Chinese to the waiters who understood no Chinese). It was the kitchen and its mind-numbing, appetite-destroying slowness. On my first visit, we ordered and then waiter nearly one full hour before our food came. On my second visit, we waited 45 minutes, and then there was always a huge delay between each dish so that everyone was nearly finished with one dish before the next one came. In a Chinese restaurant, we eat family-style, which means all the main dishes should come out together. And as if that wasn’t enough, they got our appetizers mixed up so half the appetizers came out after all the main dishes. It was so bizarre.
China Grill recommends reservations for dinner, so you’d think that they are able to control the speed of the kitchen to suit the number of customers. If you can’t handle that many customers at once, then don’t take so many reservations. But actually, the dining room was not full. Several tables were empty, so I guess the kitchen is even slower than slow.
Honestly, I’m not one to gripe about service. I love eating at holes-in-the-wall and grimy Chinatown joints whose idea of service is yelling at you to hurry up and order. But when you’re touring yourself as a higher-end, top notch restaurant that recommends reservations, I’m expecting stellar service.
However, China Grill may have gotten better recently, as I had visited within their 1st month of opening. Maybe my now, they finally got their act together and figured out the kinks. But I’m done here. If I dine there again and end up experiencing the same thing again, I’ll just be even angrier.
So now, if I have a craving for authentic Sichuan food, I’ll be driving an extra 10 minutes up to Taste of China, where I know I can dine in peace.
If you couldn’t tell already, the winner of this showdown is Taste of China!

Taste of China!
And more pictures! Because I couldn’t fit them all in the post!

Compressed tofu with bamboo shoots - China Grill

yummy! more yu xiang pork - China Grill

Pumpkin cakes - Taste of China

Water boiled beef - Taste of China

Mapo tofu - Taste of China

Twice cooked pork 回锅肉 - Taste of China

Beef Noodle Soup - Taste of China

Pork and tofu pearls rolled in sticky rice - Taste of China
China Grill
2162 Barracks Rd
Charlottesville, VA 22903
Taste of China
612 Albemarle Sq
Charlottesville, VA 22901